This week, in a 7-part series, we are settling the most delicious culinary debate in Orlando: Which park snacks from Disney and Universal are truly the most Magically Epic™?
Yesterday, Universal won the Plated Dessert Showdown, closing the gap in the series. The score currently stands at Universal 2 / Disney 3. Today, we are back to handheld treats—or, more accurately, two-handed, shareable behemoths! This battle is about size, spectacle, and ultimate sweet indulgence.
Get ready to rumble! It’s Disney’s legendary Gaston’s Giant Cinnamon Roll versus Universal’s iconic The Big Pink Donut!
Day 6: Colossal Treats!
This competition pits authentic, fresh-baked quality against sheer cinematic spectacle. Both treats are famous for their colossal size, making them the ultimate shareable dessert or single-person challenge.
Disney’s Culinary Behemoth: Gaston’s Giant Cinnamon Roll
Found at Gaston’s Tavern in Magic Kingdom, this snack is a true masterpiece of baked goods. Described as a huge, gooey, buttery roll, it is served warm, ensuring the interior is soft and utterly melt-in-your-mouth. The roll is generously topped with a thick, tangy cream cheese frosting and finished with a rich butterscotch drizzle.
The strength of Gaston’s roll is its superior quality and value. It’s not just big; it’s genuinely delicious. The combination of warm bread, cinnamon spice, and creamy, complex frosting and butterscotch elevates it beyond typical theme park fare, delivering an authentic bakery experience that is hard to match.
Universal’s Iconic Spectacle: The Big Pink Donut
Universal fights back with the instantly recognizable Big Pink Donut, available primarily at Lard Lad Donuts in the Springfield U.S.A. (Simpsons) area of the park. This treat is pure, unadulterated spectacle.
The Big Pink is a giant, yeast-style donut that perfectly recreates the cartoon confection favored by Homer Simpson. It is slathered in bright pink icing and covered in colorful sprinkles, making it one of the most Instagrammable items in the entire resort. Its appeal is rooted in nostalgia and visual novelty—it is a mandatory photo opportunity and a massive dessert designed to be shared among a group.
The Decisive Verdict
This showdown is determined by whether we value Iconic Novelty or Culinary Quality. Both items are undeniably “Colossal” and “Epic.”
The Big Pink Donut is a triumph of thematic design and size. It perfectly achieves its goal of being an iconic, shareable photo opportunity. However, compared to a fresh-baked good, the donut is simple, often described as a massive, slightly dry, sweet novelty.
Gaston’s Giant Cinnamon Roll is the winner because it successfully combines the colossal size and shareability with superior texture, warmth, and complex flavor. It provides the gooey, buttery softness that elevates a simple sweet treat into a truly Magically Epic™ experience. In this case, substance over spectacle secures the point.
WINNER: Disney (Gaston’s Giant Cinnamon Roll)
Current SNACK WARS Score: Universal 2 / Disney 4
Disney takes a commanding lead! It all comes down to the final battle!
Join us tomorrow for Day 7: Massively Epic Shareables! We’re ending the series with the ultimate sharing showdown: Disney’s legendary Kitchen Sink sundae (Beaches & Cream) versus the magnificent, towering Milkshakes from Toothsome’s Chocolate Emporium (Universal CityWalk)! This will determine the overall Snack Wars champion!
Disagree? Are you all about the iconic spectacle of The Big Pink, or does the buttery goodness of Gaston’s rule your world? Feel free to comment, like this post, subscribe, or follow us on social media! See our links for more magically epic™ content!
Leave a Reply